Online ordering powered by Seamless
1129 AMSTERDAM AVE, ()(212) 749-8924
Minimum order of $8.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Unfortunately, Hamilton Deli is not open at the delivery/pickup time that you selected. Please make sure that you've entered an address and try changing the time in the Order Information section to the right.
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $8.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 45 - 60 min (more info)
Print this menu
Available all day.
Available all day.
With lettuce and tomato.
Hamilton Deli well known on the Upper West Side and to the Columbia crowd for offering speedy and reliable service. They have a variety of sandwiches from the classic BLT to the Godfather, with all the best Italian cheese and meats! Everything is prepared quickly and delivered to you right away. Hamilton Deli uses only the freshest cold cuts and salads ensuring that every dish is of the highest possible quality. Order online or stop by Hamilton Deli today for a quick tasty lunch or snack!
didnt give me the right food.
Posted 9 months ago by Joy C.
A dreadful "Godfather's" hero, which is meant to be an Itialian Sub with next to no meat. Bad bread too. An hour for delivery for sub!
Posted 10 months ago by Michael P.
Don't order if you're hungry. I've given this place three tries and each time it took 1-1/2 hours for my food to arrive.
Posted a year ago by Carrie R.
Inexpensive, large portions, and good quality considering the low prices. A student's dream, offensive to food snobs, but what were you expecting?
Posted a year ago by Nathan J.
If I could give 0, I would... I called the restaurant looking for my order and got the run around on whether it bad left or not. After waiting an hour for a salad, the delivery guy arrived and basically refused to come upstairs. I explained to him that that isn't the way delivery works, and after a verbal fight, I coaxed him up the stairs...Horrifying...Never again...
Posted a year ago by Amanda Z.
The food was prepared fresh and delivered fast. An added bonus was the reusable containers they used. I only ordered breakfast from them but highly recommend the prices as well as the portion sizes. Really great!
Posted a year ago by Jennie M.
I have never had an issue with Hamilton deli. I ways get my food quick and its always delicious
Posted a year ago by Tanner L.
Love this place! Cheap, fresh salads, friendly delivery guys. They do take kind of a while to deliver, especially since nothing is cooked that I order, but it's always within the delivery window! At least they are honest about it.
Posted a year ago by Katherine W.
Excellent food, but they often only have 1 delivery guy on duty so it can take awhile to arrive. The salad options are great, as are all their sandwiches!
Posted a year ago by Emily T.
Decent Sandwich, On time delivery. However, the coffee spilled and soaked half the sandwich. They should have placed it in a separate bag.
Posted a year ago by Mehwash A.
5 stars for delivery and accuracy and speed of orders
3 for food freshness on the salads.
5 stars for prices
4-5 stars for serice
Overall a solid 4
Posted a year ago by Mari B.
Disgusting inedible food. Ordered three items, took one bite of each and then had to throw it all out they were so bad. I was happier eating a jar of peanuts. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. I read other reviews and decided to take a chance. I regret that. I repeat: DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. Wish I could give 0 stars.
Posted a year ago by Mitchell M.
Just ordered a Chicken Panini from here and they sent me one that had been made on Apr 29!!!! Yes, that's 5 days ago. Not happy. Had one bite and it tasted as you'd expect. Will obviously never order from here again.
Posted a year ago by Angela D.
I ordered a Monte Cristo Combination Hero and stated NO MAYO, only butter and curly fries for pick up and of course my order was wrong. I had to call them, and the person over the phone stated he will send someone out to deliver me another sandwhich which would have NO MAYO. Ten minutes later my new sandwich arrives and now i have my Monte with No mayo but soggy fries.
Posted a year ago by Kayleen S.
My first time ordering here didn't go so well, but I gave them another shot. I have since given them many more shots. Great and cheap food, 9 times out of 10 efficient delivery.
Posted a year ago by Benjamin K.
Great for late night munchies. Ordered the chicken tenders,sloppy fries and a slice of red velvet. Everything was soo good! Must try the sloppy fries. Delivery took a while though.
Posted a year ago by Nabiha Z.
Very good food and fast delivery!!!!
Posted a year ago by Daniel A.
Love ham del. have been ordering from here for the past two years and while sometimes they forget a drink, they're always fast and the food is always delicious. Definitely a go to for egg sandwiches. Curly fries are a must!!
Posted a year ago by Elizabeth A.
The worst! Order got to me an hour and a half after I ordered. It arrived COLD! Soggy. Just gross. They messed up my dessert order as well. This had totally bummed me out.
Posted a year ago by Sahar I.
Very fast delivery and good food. My only complaint is that they don't have a place to write in a tip on the credit card receipt. I never have cash on hand so I wasn't able to tip my delivery guy and I felt awful.
Posted a year ago by Janessa G.
The food is OK, but the quality of service has really gone down in the last year or so, and the delivery times are off-the-charts bad. I ordered a salad recently (with only four ingredients requested) during a non-peak hour and it took them over TWO AND A HALF HOURS to deliver it. Do yourself a favor and pick up your food there in person rather than order it online.
Posted a year ago by Tung San K.
Good food, super super fast delivery, and they know their way around Columbia.
Posted a year ago by Lori C.
Food was good and I order from Hamilton often. BUT:
The delivery guy (name: Gai) stole my number from the receipt and harassed me through text messages and on the phone, calling me babe and asking if he can come over and see me!!!!!!!!! Very scary experience. I called the police and just finished reporting it. I verified it was the delivery man by calling Hamilton Deli and asking them to read off the number of the delivery guy who just delivered my food and it was the same number!! His name is Gai and his phone number is 347-824-4417. Please be careful and watch out. I asked for him to get fired, but who knows what Hamilton will do. Let's see.
I do have to say the management was very nice about what happened. But I have no idea if they fired that guy.
Posted a year ago by Sara M.
NEVER ORDER FROM HAMDEL EVER EVER EVER EVER. MY ORDER NEVER CAME AND 4 HOURS LATER WHEN I SPOKE TO THE OWNER HE WOULDN'T JUST SIMPLY SEND ME THE FOOD. HE INSISTED THAT I DEAL WITH SEAMLESS, CANCEL THE ORDER, AND RE-ORDER RATHER THAN JUST SEND ME THE F***ING FOOD.
Posted a year ago by Juan O.
They delivered the wrong flavor of snapple and that is very upsetting.
Posted a year ago by Anna E.
Wish I could give zero stars. Ordered the Rise & Shine platter that was supposed to come with toast and home fries and neither were included in my order. My eggs were not cooked how I specified and the french toast was soggy (probably because everything was stuffed into one small takeout container). When I called to inform them of the problem they said that it must be a mistake on the website.. what? NEVER AGAIN.
Posted a year ago by Elaine K.
This is the worst deli I've ever ordered from. Period.
Posted a year ago by Dionna M.
I would give them 4 stars but they took forever. Food is GREAT! Love the paninis
Posted a year ago by Mia B.
Do NOT order from this place on the weekend. Or at least not on a Sunday. Waited almost 2 hours for my food. When I called the place (at about the 1 hour 45 minute mark), the person was unapologetic and seemed to act as if I should be sorry for HER that so many people were calling to ask about their orders, & they only had one delivery person (BAD planning!). When it FINALLY showed up, of course it was stone cold. Tried to heat it up but the eggs are hard balls (ordered sunny side up) and the turkey bacon is like rubber. They get one star because they did call to say they were out of turkey sausage - however, it would have been a good idea to let me know about the delivery situation at that point & I could have ordered from somewhere else.
Posted a year ago by Lisa J.
DO NOT ORDER DELIVERY FROM HERE! I put it an order at 10pm and by 12am it still didn't come, so I called the restaurant. They said they only had one delivery guy and there were still 11 orders before us and asked if we wanted to cancel. No we didn't want to cancel, we're expecting our food. Literally got in an argument before he nonchalantly said oh you're not that far I'll send someone now. Food comes and it is TERRIBLE, probably some of the worst food I've had in NYC. Disgusting burger, soggy fries, definitely not fresh ingredients. Save yourself the money and headache, order somewhere else!
Posted a year ago by Brittany E.
panini was microwaved not pressed like it should be
deli salads were store bought not homemade
Posted a year ago by carlene s.
Overall pretty good.
Posted a year ago by Nicole K.
Prosciutto and fresh mozzarella combo hero is awesome. Gotten delivery many times and always comes quickly. Other subs are pretty good, the prosciutto is stellar.
Posted a year ago by Kieran M.
Great food unless it takes a while and then it tends to be cold.
Posted a year ago by Shawnee T.
Forgot my brownie, delivery was fast, sandwich was good.
YES! My sandwich arrived in less than 15 minutes, even though the predicted delivery time was 45-60 mins. The sandwiches are also huge and delicious. Delivery guys are nice and know the layout of Columbia, which makes everything easier.
Posted a year ago by Megan T.
It's good for a quick affordable meal (a minimum order of $8 is rare). And they deliver as far East as Saint Nicholas. I work from home, so this is my go to place if I'm in the middle of something and can't run out for lunch.
Posted a year ago by Carla B.
Everything was soggy. I had asked for extra crispy french fries. These were soggy. The sandwich was soggy as well.
Posted a year ago by Marga R.
Ordered the turkey burger and I can't say for certain that it was turkey. Tasted like cardboard and was very dry. I ordered the chocolate cake and got a German chocolate cake instead. I really dislike coconut so it would have been nice to have to it labeled correctly to avoid this situation.
Posted a year ago by Natalie M.
seafood salad was out of stock so they called and I selected chicken salad instead - not a lot of flavor and big chunks of dry chicken. I ordered the german choc cake and they delivered some other random type of cake - no idea what it was but def not german choc cake.
Posted a year ago by Sheila R.
Speed of delivery was absolutely fantastic. The delivery guy was very nice and they followed my special instructions. He forgot my drink but I can understand how easy it is to forget the drink when rushing out for a delivery, I've done some deliveries myself. He came back with my drink within 5 mins and apologized a million times! Very great service.
Posted 2 years ago by Chelsea R.
Food is ok, but this the 2nd time I've waited over an hour. It's been an hour and 1/2 and still no food! I called, but no concrete answers on timing.
Posted 2 years ago by LaDell F.
Salad was decent. Got a large and the bowl wasn't full. Pretty generous with the toppings (though slightly limited-no avocado or tofu available) and they put in beans instead of beets.
Delivery guy is super nice though!
Posted 2 years ago by Chelsea O.
The burger was stale! Horrible food!The service was quick,it was delivered within minutes, obviously because the food was stale!
Posted 2 years ago by Ashutosh C.
The food was nearly inedible - the fries were soggy, the mozzarella sticks cold, and the burger... it didn't even taste like meat. I will not order again.
Posted 2 years ago by amanda m.
The chili cheese fries are really good. Delivery is fast. Don't order the cake. It was very stale!
Posted 2 years ago by Michelle W.
The best sandwiches around.
Posted 2 years ago by jennifer t.
Posted 2 years ago by james o.
The Godfather sandwich is good but could of used more meat to be a traditional sandwich and moz sticks were cold when delivered.
Posted 2 years ago by Alberto P.
The food was extremely greasy. They gave me the wrong dessert & it was so dry & hard. The panini was gross. I won't order from here again.
Posted 2 years ago by Darlene L.
Got food poisoning from here. Enough said. Never order from here.
Posted 2 years ago by David K.
Come on, don't hate on HamDel! For what it is, the food is tasty, hot and good. I do recommend pickup over delivery, but whenever I need my breakfast sandwich brought to my door on a particularly rough Saturday or Sunday morning, it gets there fast and hot.
Posted 2 years ago by Justine d.
Food arrived 20 minutes late, was cold and did not contain everything we ordered. Quality of food was not great either.
Posted 2 years ago by Chelsea B.
30 min. Sandwich arrived hot and ready to eat.
Posted 2 years ago by Greg V.
Delivery was super quick and food was hot and delicious! Definitely a go to for a great sandwich!
Posted 2 years ago by jacqui w.
took two hours to show up
Posted 2 years ago by sean t.
miserable. salad smelled awful and my sandwich was so gross I couldn't eat half of it.
Posted 2 years ago by jonathan h.
I got a BLT and asked for the tomato on the side with a side on mayo.... i called to remind the people at the deli... i got the sandwich a hour later with the tomato on it and with no mayo.... I called and talk to the front desk person and they said i dont care and hung up the phone....yea i probably wont be ordering from there again
Posted 2 years ago by Marissa F.
threw away the tuna fish sandwich. it was very gross.
Posted 2 years ago by Rob R.
It took my order 1 hour and 45 minutes to arrive. When I called after a half hour, they said it was on its way. A half hour later, they said the delivery man had other stops to make and it would be here within 30 minutes (2 hour after I ordered). They said it was because I was really far away (15 blocks) and they only had one delivery man. Long story short: unless you are right around the corner, don't order from here. They admitted that their delivery estimates on Seamless are incorrect and that this timing was typical for someone so "far away." When I told them that perhaps they shouldn't deliver so far then, they just agreed with me. They were nice about it, but still...."far away" buyers beware.
Posted 2 years ago by Jessica S.
Delivery guys are so nice and the food is great and came piping hot! Sausage egg and cheese wrap is to die for :)
Posted 2 years ago by Lillian V.
used to be a great deli and I ordered from them frequently, but the last time was truly the LAST time...food arrived late, not as ordered and I wound up with a bad bout of food poisoning, they've really slipped, I advise you to try somewhere else
Posted 2 years ago by Scott M.
Food arrived in 15 minutes! That's fast!! Sandwich not hot but still warm (it's windy and below freezing today so I am happy with warm). Grateful I didn't have to be the one out there. Satisfied and eating my delicious sandwich (the twister hero) right now.
Posted 2 years ago by Christina G.
Took 90 minutes. When it arrived my chicken soup was spilled all over my grilled cheese sandwich.
Posted 2 years ago by Alex F.
Worst experience ever ordering food. Two and a half hours and got wrong order after being quoted 30-45 minutes.
Posted 2 years ago by Kane F.
Sandwich showed up cold and soggy. Terrible
Posted 2 years ago by Dale M.
All the other reviewers are right about this place - they just don't pay attention to what is being ordered. I ordered an eggplant parm sandwich with extra sauce on the side and instead got a grilled eggplant sandwich with some kind of peppers and onions concoction thrown on top (which I hate) - no sauce in sight, forget extra, and they completely ignored my bread preference instructions even though I gave them alternatives if they didn't have my first choice. If I could give this place 0 stars I would!
Posted 3 years ago by Ishween S.
Constantly given the wrong items! For example, my cheeseburger had no lettuce and tomato (as stated on the website) and they didn't even include a single packet of ketchup. Another time, they gave me a 2 liter Coke instead of Diet Coke. When I asked why, they said it was because they were out. They couldn't have called? I can't drink soda with sugar due to dietary restrictions.
I won't order here again.
Posted 3 years ago by Lindsay R.
chicken parm was just bread and chicken, motz sticks weren't cooked enough, fries were so so
Posted 3 years ago by stephen l.
Stale bread, two entirely different (one hot and one cold) and tasteless sandwiches, horribly soggy French fries (admittedly hard to do well, but given the ratings we thought they would hit this out of the park) ... and they forgot to deliver the dessert. Most of the order went into the garbage. Will not reorder from Hamilton again.
Posted 3 years ago by Bonita V.
Food is decent and delivery is very quick, which was my main reason for ordering from them, but they do not read the special instructions for their orders. This could happen to anybody and if it doesn't happen that often it's not a big deal- I would not have had a problem with it if, when I called, they had just sent out the updated correct order. Instead, they called me back to argue about how it's not their fault that their menu is poorly organized to allow for options, and it's also not their fault that they didn't read my request. Pretty sure that's my last order from these guys.
Posted 3 years ago by Terri H.
forgot my orange juice, no cheese on my eggplant sandwich. You get what you pay for.
Posted 3 years ago by Morgan L.
I ordered a whole-wheat sandwich and a bagel, but received a white-bread version and a roll. Whoever attending my call was quite rude, saying that they do not have whole wheat hero and ran out of bagels. I told him that he should have called me if he wanted to modify my order. He told me to call them first next time after placing an order on seamless, and he said he would give me a refund and i could keep the food, but then he instantly called back to demand me to return the food. And i had to contact seamless in the end to get a refund. This is frustrating enough to void my pleasant experience with Hamilton Deli for the last two years. Be responsible for your own business. If you don't have something, do not put it on the option. Call a customer for a ran-out item, because we expect that the food is there.
Posted 3 years ago by Jinhee R.
Very exceptional service! Fast delivery. I have had three of their sandwiches, all of which are simple and delish. I love to try a new one every week.. AND their prices are very decent. Some of the restaurants on here charge you 3 bucks for a can of Coke (Cascabel Tacueria, I'm pointing at you!)! SImple, yet consistent... they haven't let me down yet. :)
Posted 3 years ago by Eric T.
Hardly any chicken salad on my sandwich, served on a stale hero and the fries almost unedible.
Posted 3 years ago by Meaghan C.
Inexpensive and decent lunch place for sandwiches, salads, etc.
Posted 3 years ago by Duane L.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Hamilton Deli's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from
Hamilton Deli by entering your address
below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.